Spread the love
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  

Child safety seat ratings

All child safety seats rated by the NHTSA (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration) have to meet strict federal guidelines ( Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) No. 213, Child Restraint Systems) when it comes to crash testing and safety. There is, however, another test that the NHTSA conduct to help guide parents on child safety seats. It’s called the Child Safety Ease Of Use Rating.

car seat safety ease

Not all seats and vehicles are a good match

As a parent, I can tell you first hand that moving car seats is not my favorite past time. If I remember one time having to use a rental vehicle and it took me probably a good 30 minutes to get the car seat in. I was almost to the point of tears in frustration that I couldn’t get the latches to click in or the car seat to sit in the right position in the mini van seat. This is where the NHTSA ‘s rating might have come in handy. Although I will point out that not all seats in vehicles are created equally and whilst one child safety seat might fit well in one car, doesn’t mean it’ll fit well in another.

How is the ease of use rating calculated?

Factors taken into consideration when rating the child safety seats are;

  • Instructions – content and clarity of the instruction manual with the seat
  • Vehicle installation features – how easy is the car seat to install into a vehicle
  • Labels – content and clarity of the labels on the car seat
  • Securing the child in the seat – How easy is it to buckle up/secure the child in the seat

The NHTSA then uses a star-based rating system depending on how good the seat scores in each of the above categories.

  • 5 Stars = Excellent features on this child restraint for this category.
  • 4 Stars = Above-average features on this child restraint for this category.
  • 3 Stars = Average features on this child restraint for this category.
  • 2 Stars = Below-average features on this child restraint for this category.
  • 1 Star = Poor features on this child restraint for this category.
  • N/A = Does not contain any features that require a rating ¹

 

So, given this information, I have compiled a list for you, of the top-rated child safety seats that scored 5 stars for ease of use on the NHTSA chart. This does not mean that these seats are any safer, it merely states that they are easier to use.

The first column is the brand and name of the seat. The second column is the model number and manufacture date. The third column is harness type and the fourth is the weight/height of the child that the safety seat is designed for. RF means rear facing, FF is front facing, B is for booster.

kids car seat

 

Infant seats that scored 5 stars overall for ease of use

 

Baby Trend Inertia (RF)CS58743  /  Feb 25, 20135-pt5lb – 32lb / up to 32″
Britax B-Safe 35 (RF)        E9LS63F  /  Jan 1, 20155-pt4lb – 35lb / up to 32″
Britax B-Safe 35 Elite (RF)E9LS56P  /  Dec 1, 20145-pt4lb – 35lb / up to 32″
Combi Shuttle (RF)              8035136  /  Apr 15, 20135-ptup to 35lb / up to 33″
Cybex Aton Q (RF)12-4020004  /  Nov 1, 20145-pt4lb – 35lb / up to 30″
Doona Infant Seat (RF)SP101-10-002-003  /  Jan 7, 20165-pt4lb – 35lb / up to 32″
GB Asana 35 (RF)25HA1G-FUZ2U  /  Oct 26, 20145-pt4lb – 35lb / up to 32″
Ingenuity InTrust35 Pro (RF)60275  /  Dec 25, 20145-pt4lb – 35lb / up to 32″
JJ Cole Newport Infant Seat (RF)I470 GRDRP  /  Jul 24, 20125-pt5lb – 35lb / up to 32″
The First Years Contigo (RF)I480-BKKH  /  Jan 15, 20135-pt5lb – 35lb / up to 32″
UPPAbaby Mesa (RF)MSA50215UO05020  /  Feb 1, 20155-pt4lb – 35lb / up to 32″

 

Surpised by this list as much as I was? Yeh, if you are a parent and are familiar with car seat brands, you’ll likely have noticed there are some big names not in that list. Want to see how they did, check out the full list here.

Convertible seats that scored 5 stars for overall ease of use

Britax Advocate ClickTight (FF)E9LT95N  /  Feb 1, 20155-pt20lb – 65lb / up to 49″
Britax Boulevard ClickTight (FF)E9LT85Q  /  Feb 1, 20155-pt20lb – 65lb / up to 49″
Britax Marathon ClickTight (FF)E9LT76L  /  Jan 1, 20155-pt20lb – 65lb / up to 49″
The First Years True Fit I-Alert (RF)C685-BKKH  /  Jan 15, 20135-pt5lb – 35lb / top of head 1″ from top of seat
The First Years True Fit I-Alert (FF)C685-BKKH  /  Jan 15, 20135-pt23lb – 65lb / up to 50″
The First Years True Fit SI (RF)C680-POT  /  Jan 4, 20135-pt5lb – 35lb / top of head 1″ from top of seat
The First Years True Fit SI (FF)C680-POT  /  Jan 4, 20135-pt23lb – 65lb / up to 50″

There are over 100 child safety seats in this section of the list and only the above 7 seats had over 5 star ease of use rating. Worryingly, quite a few seats that were evaluated on the list had only 1 star for installation features.

Combination seats that scored 5 stars for overall ease of use

Britax Frontier 90 (FF)E9LH34L  /  Apr 1, 20135-pt25lb – 90lb / 30″ – 58″
Britax Pinnacle 90 (FF)E9LL94Q  /  May 1, 20135-pt25lb – 90lb / 30″ – 58″
Britax Pioneer 70 (FF)E9LH43G  /  Jun 1, 20135-pt25lb – 70lb / 30″ – 54″
Evenflo SecureKid (B)30831269  /  Apr 26, 2016Highback40lb – 110lb / 43.3″ – 57″
Graco Atlas 65 (B)1946242  /  Oct 22, 2015Highback30lb – 100lb / 38″ – 57″
Snugli Booster Car Seat (B)30821162  /  Mar 10, 2015Highback40lb – 110lb / 43.3″ – 57″

 

3 in 1 child safety seats that scored an overall 5 stars for ease of use

Graco Milestone (B)1926538  /  Dec 3, 2014Highback30lb – 100lb / 38″ – 57″
Graco Smart Seat (B)1802320  /  Oct 16, 2015Highback30lb – 100lb / 38″ – 57″

 

Booster seats that score an overall 5 stars for ease of use

Cybex Solution X-Fix (B)514116019  /  Feb 1, 2016 Highback33lb – 100lb / 38″ – 60″
Dream on Me Car Booster Seat (B)377  /  May 15, 2014No Back30lb – 100lb / 34″ – 57″
Evenflo Amp Highback (B)31911431  /  Mar 4, 2014Highback/No Back30lb – 110lb / 40″ – 57″
Evenflo Big Kid LX (B)31411373  /  Jan 10, 2014Highback/No Back30lb – 110lb / 38″ – 57″
Learning Curve B540 (B)B540-POP OF TEAL  /  Jul 8, 2013Highback30lb – 100lb / 38″ – 57″

 

Find out if your car seat has been tested for ease of use, here.

Before purchasing a new vehicle, I highly recommend that you try your child safety seats in there first. It is not always the case that a ‘family friendly’ vehicle is easy to put car seats in.

 

¹“Car Seat Ease-of-Use Ratings.” Www.safercar.gov, NHTSA, www.safercar.gov/parents/CarSeats/Car-Seat-Ratings-Ease-Of-Use.htm?view=full

 

Lauren has been working in the automotive industry both in the U.K and in the U.S. for over 10 years. A car geek, photographer, big game chaser and bagpipe player, powered by coffee. Send your questions to:

lauren@trustedautopros.com

Subscribe To Our Updates!

Subscribe To Our Updates!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest posts and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

%d bloggers like this: